I’ve worked nights as a security guard at a few places, and the self storage horror story I’m about to tell is the only one that made me quit. Self storage is supposed to be the easiest gig there is. Rows of metal doors, a gate code, a golf cart. You drive around and make sure the locks are on. My problem was that one lock kept changing.
In 2022 I worked overnights, 10 p.m. to 6 a.m., at a big storage facility off a highway outside Ocala, Florida. Four hundred and some units in long one-story buildings, a gated lot for boats and RVs, and a little office with a camera monitor and a coffee maker. My job was simple. Drive the golf cart around every two hours, check every door, and write down anything unusual in the log. Overlocks, cut locks, open doors.
An overlock is a second lock the company puts on a unit when the renter stops paying. It’s bright orange, so it’s easy to spot. If a renter goes long enough without paying, the unit goes to auction.
Unit 114
Unit 114 was in Building C, about halfway down. A ten-by-fifteen. It had an orange overlock on it when I started that job in March, plus the renter’s own lock, a regular brass padlock. The office manager, a woman named Deb, told me the renter hadn’t paid in nine months. The unit was scheduled for auction in May.
On my second week, I drove past 114 at 2 a.m. The orange overlock was there. But the renter’s brass padlock was gone. In its place was a silver one. Brand new. The shiny kind you buy in a blister pack at a hardware store.
I wrote it in the log. “Unit C114, renter lock changed?” Deb said in the morning that maybe she was misremembering. It happens.
The next night, at 2 a.m., it was a black padlock. Combination dial. The silver one was gone.
The night after that, a little blue one. Then a long-shackle brass one. Then a steel one with a rubber cover. Every night, a different lock. The orange overlock was always there, untouched.
A Self Storage Horror Story Needs a Gate Code
You can’t get into that facility at night without a gate code, and the gate logs every code that’s used. I checked the log. Nobody had come through the gate after 9 p.m. on any of those nights. Not once.
I checked the cameras. There’s a camera at each end of Building C. Unit 114 is in the middle, just out of range of both. Somebody knew that.
I told myself it was a prank. The day guy, maybe. Or Deb, who had a dry sense of humor. I asked them both. Deb looked at me like I was nuts. The day guy, a retired cop named Wendell, didn’t laugh. He said, “You writing it down?” I said yes. He said, “Keep writing it down.”
I bought a cheap trail camera with my own money and strapped it to the gutter across from 114, pointed at the door. I set it to take a picture whenever it saw motion.
What the Camera Saw
I checked it after my shift. There were forty-one pictures. Most were moths. Some were me in the golf cart, every two hours, like clockwork.
Then, at 3:52 a.m., the door of unit 114 was open a foot at the bottom. Rolled up from inside. Under the overlock, which was still locked. Overlocks go on the latch of the door. They don’t stop a door from being lifted a little from inside, if somebody inside has loosened the track.
In the next picture, at 3:53, a hand was coming out through the gap. A thin, pale hand, holding a padlock. In the next one, the hand was hooking the new lock on the hasp. In the one after that, the door was back down, and the new lock was in place.
The whole time, unit 114 had been locked from the outside. Somebody was inside it. Every night, they swapped the lock from inside so that the lock would be different in the morning. As far as I could tell, for no reason except to show someone they were there.
To show me.
The Auction
I gave the pictures to Deb. She called the sheriff. Two deputies came at 9 a.m. They cut the overlock and the new padlock and rolled up the door.
The unit was full of furniture. Old stuff, an estate’s worth. Dressers, a dining table, boxes of dishes. In the back, behind the dining table, somebody had made a little room. A mattress. A battery lantern. A cooler. Jugs of water. A bucket. And on a card table, in a neat row, padlocks. Dozens of them, of every kind, every color. Each one had a small piece of masking tape on it with a date.
And a notebook. Deb read it before the deputies took it. It was a log, like mine. Every night, the times I drove past. “Guard 12:04.” “Guard 2:01.” “Guard stopped. Looked at lock. Smiled.” “Guard wrote something.”
The renter of 114 was a man named in the contract as Walter Fry. His address was a house that had been sold the year before. Nobody knew where he was. Nobody was in the unit. The deputies said he must have left during the day, when the gate was busy, and nobody would notice one more person walking out.
The unit went to auction in May. A man from Gainesville bought it for three hundred dollars. When he cleaned it out, he called Deb. He said there was a new padlock on the inside of the door, hooked through the track. He said it wasn’t there when he bid.
I quit at the end of that week. Wendell still works there. He says the lock on 114 hasn’t changed since. These are horror stories to tell late at night, and I’ve told this one a lot. People usually want creepy stories to read about haunted places. This is just a storage unit. One of thousands. If you ever go to an auction, look inside the door first. Some long horror stories don’t end. They just get rented to someone new.
What’s in your storage unit?
Do you have a self storage horror story from working nights, buying units at auction or just visiting your own unit after dark? Tell us in the comments.
Read gas station horror stories and night shift hotel horror story for more from the night shift.
How scary was it?
More Night Shift Horror Stories
The Whiteboard in an Empty Hospital Room Kept Writing My Name
The Props in Our Halloween Store Kept Going Off After We Closed
Someone Kept Setting a 3:10 Wake-Up Call in Room 214
Our Funeral Home Van Drove Itself 14.6 Miles Every Night
A 911 Call Came From Inside Our Dispatch Center at 3:02 Every Night
Corporate Kept Calling the Gas Station at 2 A.M. to Send Me Outside