Every Morning There Was a New Roasting Stick Carved With One of Our Initials

Four carved wooden roasting sticks leaning on a stone fire ring in a dark Wisconsin forest, creepy campfire stories

Most creepy campfire stories are about something out in the dark. Ours is about something that came right up to the fire ring while we slept and left a gift. Four gifts, actually. Then a fifth one, for somebody who wasn’t even there yet. I work at a print shop in Eau Claire, Wisconsin. In … Read more

Someone Marked My Trail With Orange Ribbons While I Walked It

Strip of orange surveyor ribbon tied to a branch in a foggy Appalachian forest, appalachian mountain scary stories

Growing up in West Virginia, I heard a lot of Appalachian mountain scary stories. Lights on the ridge, voices that call your name, things you don’t whistle at after dark. I never believed any of them. Then I went mushroom hunting alone in the Monongahela National Forest, and somebody marked my trail behind me with … Read more

An Empty Tent Moved Closer to My Ranger Cabin Every Night

Old green dome tent pitched beside a log cabin wall at dawn in the mountains, scary park ranger stories

People always ask wilderness rangers for scary park ranger stories. I usually tell them about the bear that took a whole cooler or the guy who tried to hike out in flip-flops. I don’t tell this one. This is the empty tent that moved closer to my cabin every night. Other rangers trade park ranger … Read more

A Tree Stand Moved Closer to Mine Every Weekend

Empty hang-on tree stand high on a trunk in a gray November forest at dawn, scary hunting stories

Every deer camp has its scary hunting stories. Most of them are about getting lost, or a bear, or a buck that charged somebody’s uncle in 1974. Mine is about a second tree stand that showed up across the hollow from mine, facing my stand instead of the deer trail, and moving a little closer … Read more

Something in the Trees Learned My Dad’s Knock

Old log cabin door at night in a dark Cascade forest with a huge footprint in the mud, scary bigfoot stories

I always thought scary bigfoot stories were for people who wear camo to the grocery store. Then my dad and I spent a weekend at his cabin in the Washington Cascades, and something in the trees learned his knock. I’d heard plenty of bigfoot horror stories from guys at the gas station. None of them … Read more

A Stranger Sat in Our Spare Chair and Told a Story About Us

Empty canvas camp chair beside a campfire in a dark Ozark forest, scary campfire stories

My friends and I have told scary campfire stories every Halloween weekend for ten years. This is the year a stranger walked out of the dark, sat down in the fifth chair, and told one about us. We’ve heard a lot of terrifying campfire stories at that fire ring, and this is the one none … Read more

My Trail Cam Caught a Man Wearing My Dad’s Jacket

Grainy night vision photo of a figure in a plaid jacket beside a small tent, trail cam horror story

This trail cam horror story begins with a missing wool jacket at a campsite in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula, and an animal I was sure had dragged it away. Then I got home and looked at what my camera caught at 2:13 in the morning. I lost my dad’s jacket on a camping trip in September … Read more

The Geocache Log Was Signed in One Handwriting

Rusty ammo can under a split boulder in a dark forest with an open notebook, creepy geocaching story

This creepy geocaching story starts with an old ammo can on a ridge in western North Carolina and a paper log that should have been ordinary. Every name in that log was different, but every line was written by the same hand, and the last one was written for me. I’ve been geocaching for six … Read more