Someone Marked My Trail With Orange Ribbons While I Walked It

Strip of orange surveyor ribbon tied to a branch in a foggy Appalachian forest, appalachian mountain scary stories

Growing up in West Virginia, I heard a lot of Appalachian mountain scary stories. Lights on the ridge, voices that call your name, things you don’t whistle at after dark. I never believed any of them. Then I went mushroom hunting alone in the Monongahela National Forest, and somebody marked my trail behind me with … Read more

A Voice on My CB Counted Down the Miles to Where He Was Waiting

CB radio handset glowing in a dark truck cab on an empty desert interstate, trucker scary stories

I’ve driven a truck for twenty-six years, and I’ve heard a lot of trucker scary stories at a lot of truck stop counters. Most of them are made up. This one isn’t. Somebody on my CB radio counted down the mile markers to where he was waiting for me. Most scary stories from truck drivers … Read more

Three Bus Passengers Got Off for Pie at June’s Cafe and Never Got Back On

Small roadside diner at dusk with a bus parked out front on an empty highway, small town crime story

This small town crime story was never in any newspaper. It’s about a diner on a bus route in western Nebraska, three passengers who got off for pie and never got back on, and the man our town blamed for it. My mother waitressed at that diner for eleven years. She told me the rest … Read more

My Robot Vacuum Kept Cleaning Around Something in My Empty Apartment

Robot vacuum app map showing a round blocked spot beside a bed, scary apartment stories

Most scary apartment stories are about noises through the wall. Mine is about my robot vacuum, and the obstacle it kept bumping into in the middle of my empty living room while I was at work. I know most scary stories to read online are made up, so I’m going to tell this one exactly … Read more

One Buyer Bought Something From Every Room in My House

Brass floor lamp glowing beside a rocking chair in a dark basement corner, facebook marketplace horror story

My Facebook Marketplace horror story started with a lamp. A nice man bought it for twenty dollars, carried it to his truck himself, and asked me which room it had been in. Over the next six weeks, he bought something from every room in my house. It reads like one of those creepy short stories … Read more

A 911 Call Came From Inside Our Dispatch Center at 3:02 Every Night

Dispatch console with a glowing phone line light in a dark room at night, 911 dispatcher horror story

This 911 dispatcher horror story is about one call. It came in three nights in a row at 3:02 a.m., always the same whisper, always from inside the building I was sitting in. Dispatchers collect terrifying tales to tell at night. This is the one I don’t tell new hires. I was a 911 dispatcher … Read more

Our EVP Recorder Caught a Voice Answering Our Questions, and It Was Mine

Digital voice recorder on the floor of an abandoned brick room with old iron beds, ghost hunting stories

Most ghost hunting stories you see online are fake. I know because I used to make them. My friend Corey and I ran a small ghost hunting channel for two years, and we were not above a little creative editing. But the night we spent at an old county poor farm in Indiana, our recorder … Read more

An Empty Tent Moved Closer to My Ranger Cabin Every Night

Old green dome tent pitched beside a log cabin wall at dawn in the mountains, scary park ranger stories

People always ask wilderness rangers for scary park ranger stories. I usually tell them about the bear that took a whole cooler or the guy who tried to hike out in flip-flops. I don’t tell this one. This is the empty tent that moved closer to my cabin every night. Other rangers trade park ranger … Read more

The Payphone at the Rest Stop Rang, and It Was for Me

Old payphone on a brick wall at a rainy highway rest area at night, rest stop horror story

I didn’t know payphones still rang until the one at a rest area in southern Oregon rang right as I walked past it. That’s how my rest stop horror story starts. A man’s voice on the other end said, “You’re the white Civic. Don’t go back to your car yet.” It sounds like a scary … Read more

The Last Family in Fenwick Never Left the Town Under the Lake

Glowing farmhouse window deep under dark lake water below a small boat, small town ghost story

Every fisherman on Kell Lake has heard the small town ghost story about the lights under the water. On calm nights in late fall, people say you can see a yellow window glowing far down below the boat, right where the town of Fenwick used to be. I volunteer at the county archive, and I’m … Read more