Our Neighborhood Watch Captain Kept a Notebook on Every House

Composition notebook of handwritten times on a truck dashboard facing dark houses, neighborhood watch horror story

This neighborhood watch horror story starts with a pecan pie and a friendly question about what time my truck left in the morning. By fall I had seen the captain’s notebook, and I knew why the families who “moved away” never came back for their things. The first thing our neighborhood watch captain ever asked … Read more

The Note in My Rental’s House Binder Was Written by the Man Upstairs

Closed attic hatch in a dim hallway ceiling above an open house binder, hinting at someone living in my attic

I never once suspected someone living in my attic, because the house binder told me there was nothing up there. The note was friendly, neat and helpful, and it was written by the one person who needed me to believe it. When you take a six-month job in a city where you don’t know a … Read more

My Dog Wouldn’t Go in the Laundry Room, and the Dryer Was Always Warm

Dark laundry room with a louvered water heater cabinet slightly open, a scene of someone hiding in my house

My dog figured out there was someone hiding in my house about three weeks before I did. I just kept explaining her away, along with the socks, the towel, and the dryer that was warm every time I opened it. I’m a high school band director, which means from August to November I basically live … Read more

Somebody Kept Refilling My Halloween Candy Bowl From Inside My House

Orange candy bowl full of peppermints on a dark porch beside a front door, from a home intruder story

This home intruder story starts with a bowl of candy I left on my porch on Halloween night. By morning somebody had filled it back up, and my doorbell camera swore nobody had walked up to my door. I work twelve-hour nights as a respiratory therapist, which means I miss most holidays, and Halloween is … Read more

Every Trunk Was Open and Nobody Was There

Row of cars with open decorated trunks in an empty church lot at night, trunk or treat horror story

This trunk or treat horror story happened on Halloween night on a two-lane road in the middle of nowhere. I pulled into a church lot to ask for directions, and every car there was ready for kids, except there were no people at all. It was Halloween, around ten at night. I was driving back … Read more