The Car That Followed Me for 40 Miles

the car that followed me

The story of the car that followed me for forty miles began on a long, empty stretch of interstate, about forty miles from home. At first I didn’t think anything of it — just another pair of headlights, just another late-night driver heading the same way I was. But they never passed. They never fell … Read more

The Sexton’s Diary and the Bell That Rang at 3 A.M

Open leather diary beside a coiled bell rope on a church pew at night, small town mystery story

I paid four dollars for a dead sexton’s diary, and it turned into the strangest small town mystery story I’ve ever pieced together from paper. In 1974 the church bell in Elmfors rang by itself at 3 a.m. on three nights, and the next day the pastor’s grown daughter was gone. I paid four dollars … Read more

Every Fire in Our Town Started on a Tuesday

Old dispatch desk with a green ink logbook and a distant house fire glowing through the window, small town horror story

My grandmother’s deathbed confession is the only small town horror story I know that comes with time stamps. Every fire in our town started on a Tuesday, and the fire chief everybody loved always called it in before anyone else saw smoke. My grandmother told me the worst thing she ever did eleven days before … Read more