Most creepy text stories are about a wrong number that turns out to be right. Mine is about the man I sold my old phone to, and the texts he sent me about my life that he shouldn’t have been able to see. If you’ve read scary stories text threads online, you know how they usually end. Mine didn’t.
In April of 2022, I upgraded my phone and sold the old one online. I’m a dental office manager in Columbus, Ohio. I live alone in a duplex in Clintonville with a cat named Biscuit. The old phone was in good shape, so I listed it for a hundred and fifty dollars on a local selling app.
A man messaged me within an hour. Polite. Good grammar. He asked if we could meet in the parking lot of a grocery store near me. I said sure. Public place. Daylight.
He was maybe thirty-five. Glasses, a gray zip-up jacket, very ordinary. He looked the phone over and paid me in cash. Then he asked, “Did you already reset it?”
I said I’d meant to but hadn’t gotten to it. I offered to do it right there.
He smiled and said, “Don’t worry about it. I’ll do it when I get home. I do this all the time.” And he put it in his pocket and left.
I thought that was nice of him. It saved me ten minutes.
“Nice Coffee”
About a week later, I got a text from a number I didn’t know.
“Nice coffee.”
I didn’t answer. I figured wrong number. But that morning I’d gotten a latte with a little heart in the foam and taken a picture of it, because it was cute. I didn’t post it anywhere. I just took it.
I told myself it was a coincidence. Lots of people get coffee.
Two days later. “Your sister’s dog is getting big.”
I’d been at my sister’s house that weekend and taken about thirty pictures of her golden retriever puppy. I hadn’t posted those either.
I texted back, “Who is this?”
No answer.
The next one came on a Thursday night at 10:40. “You should get that light fixed in your bathroom.”
The light over my bathroom mirror had been flickering for a month. That afternoon I’d taken a picture of the fixture to show the guy at the hardware store which bulb I needed.
The Creepy Text Stories Nobody Warns You About
I sat on my bed and went through my phone looking for answers. I don’t know much about technology. I’m good with scheduling software and insurance codes. But my nephew is sixteen and knows everything, so I called him.
He asked me one question. “Did you sign out of your account on the old phone before you sold it?”
I hadn’t. I hadn’t reset it. The man said he’d do it.
My nephew walked me through my account settings over the phone. Under “Devices,” there were two phones listed. My new one. And my old one, still signed in. Still syncing.
Every picture I took on my new phone was going straight to my cloud account. And my old phone, in a stranger’s pocket, was still signed into that same account. Every picture I’d taken for two weeks, he’d seen. My coffee. My sister’s dog. My bathroom.
My nephew said to remove the old phone from my account and change my password. Right now. I was doing it with shaking hands when another text came in.
“You left the back door unlocked.”
The Back Door
I had a smart lock on my back door. The kind you can lock and unlock with an app. I’d set it up a year before, on my old phone.
I hadn’t thought about the app. I didn’t even know if it was still logged in on the old phone. I opened the app on my new phone.
The back door said “Unlocked.” The history said it had been unlocked from the app eight minutes ago. Not from my phone.
I was sitting on my bed. My bedroom is at the back of the duplex, right off the kitchen. The back door is in the kitchen.
I didn’t hear anything. The house was quiet. Biscuit was sitting on my dresser, staring at my bedroom door with his ears flat back.
I hit “Lock” on the app. I heard the back door lock click shut in the kitchen. That little motor sound.
And then, about three seconds later, I heard it click again. Unlocking.
I called 911. I locked my bedroom door and pushed my dresser in front of it and sat on the floor behind the bed with Biscuit in my arms. The dispatcher stayed on the line. I could hear the lock in the kitchen. Lock. Unlock. Lock. Unlock. Somebody was playing with it.
Then a text. “Relax. Just checking it works.”
What the Police Found
The police came in six minutes. The back door was unlocked. Nobody was inside. Nothing was missing. There were muddy footprints on the back steps that didn’t go past the doormat.
One of the officers was young and good with phones. He looked at my account and showed me something my nephew hadn’t. Under my old phone, there was a little map. The phone’s last location.
It was two blocks away. A rental house on the next street over. You could see its roof from my back yard.
The police went there. A man answered. He said he’d bought a used phone online but it didn’t work right, so he’d sold it again to somebody else on the same app. He said he didn’t remember who. They couldn’t prove otherwise. They couldn’t find the phone.
The man had lived in that rental house for six months. He’d moved there in October. I’d listed my old phone in April. He didn’t find my listing by accident. He’d been two blocks away from me for six months, waiting for a reason to meet me in a parking lot.
I moved in June. New town. New phone number. I removed every device from every account I own. I check the “Devices” list every week now, the way some people check their locks.
I sold the smart lock to a friend of a friend. It seemed like the right thing to do at the time.
Last month I got a text from a number I didn’t know.
“Nice new place.”
I hadn’t taken any pictures of it.
If you followed this horror story text by text, you might like more strangers who know too much. Read the rideshare horror story about the passenger who always asked for the same song, our dating app horror story about a squeaky stair, or a train horror story from a crossing in Kansas.
Do you have creepy text stories?
Have you ever gotten a message from a stranger that knew something it shouldn’t? Share your creepy text stories, or any horror text stories that started with something you sold, in the comments below.
How scary was it?
More Creepy Stalker Stories
Someone Kept Returning Things I Didn’t Know I’d Lost
One Buyer Bought Something From Every Room in My House
My Date Knew About the Squeaky Stair in a House She’d Never Seen
Someone Wore My Handmade Halloween Costume to Three Parties
The Car Ahead Paid for My Coffee Every Morning
My Quiet Rideshare Passenger Always Asked for the Same Song