This fake detour horror story starts on an empty Nebraska highway at midnight, with orange signs that looked exactly like every detour I’d ever followed. A deputy later told me there was no roadwork anywhere on that road, and then he showed me how they picked my car.
The detour signs looked exactly like every detour sign I’d ever followed. That was the whole point, and it took a sheriff’s deputy to explain it to me.
I adjust crop insurance claims in south-central Nebraska. Fall is my busy season. Hail, wind, early freeze, whatever took the corn or the beans that year, I’m the guy who drives out, walks the field, and does the math. In November of 2023 I was putting six hundred miles a week on my Impala, mostly two-lane highways and section-line gravel.
That night I’d finished a late appointment down near the Kansas line. The farmer wanted to walk every acre with me, and then his wife fed me pot roast, and you don’t say no to that. So I didn’t start home to Hastings until after ten.
I stopped for gas in a little town on Highway 4. Two pumps, a cooler of night crawlers by the door, a kid behind the counter watching something on his phone. I was the only car at the pumps.
There was a pickup parked off to the side by the air hose. Dark red Chevy, older. A man was leaning on it with a coffee cup, just watching the road. Sixties maybe. Seed cap, canvas coat. He looked like half the men I talk to for a living.
While I pumped, he wandered over. Friendly.
“Long day?”
I said they’re all long this time of year.
“Which way you headed?”
“West. Hastings.”
He nodded like that was a good answer. “Roads out that way are all tore up,” he said. “Fall construction. Watch for the orange.”
Then he walked around the back of my car and tapped the trunk twice with his knuckles.
“You know your driver’s side taillight’s out?”
I didn’t. I walked back and looked, and sure enough, the left one was dark. I thanked him. He said, “Drive safe now,” and went back to his truck. I went in, paid, bought a coffee and a bag of sunflower seeds, and pulled out. The clock on my dash said 11:04.
I didn’t think about that man again for almost two hours. He was a nice old guy who told me my light was out. That’s Nebraska.
Flashing Amber Over the Rise
About twenty-five minutes west, I came over a rise and saw flashing amber.
It was a full setup. A barricade across my lane with a flasher on top, a ROAD CLOSED AHEAD sign, and a big orange DETOUR sign with an arrow pointing right, onto a gravel county road. Cones. Everything.
I’d been warned. Fall construction. I turned right.
The first mile, I didn’t think twice. There was another DETOUR sign at the first crossroad, arrow pointing left, west. Then another one two miles later, pointing left again, onto a narrower road. That’s how detours work out there. They push you over a few sections and bring you back.
Except nothing brought me back.
After the third sign, there weren’t any more. Just gravel, corn stubble on both sides, and my headlights. The road ran west, then bent north. I kept waiting for an arrow pointing me back toward the highway. I figured I’d missed one.
My phone said No Service. My GPS showed me as a blue dot in a blank gray grid.
I’ll tell you what I was thinking, because it sounds so dumb now. I was thinking the county did a lousy job with the signs, and I was going to get home late, and I’d call somebody about it in the morning.
The Truck on the Field Approach
That’s when I passed the truck.
It was parked at a crossroad with its lights off, pulled up on a field approach, nose out. I only saw it because my headlights swept across the side of it as I went by. Dark color. Older pickup.
I thought, somebody sleeping it off. Or a couple of kids parking. You see that out there.
About half a mile on, I looked in my mirror and saw nothing. Then I looked again and saw the faintest red shape back there. My one working taillight, bouncing off a chrome grille.
Something was following me with its headlights off.
I slowed down. It slowed down. When I cracked my window, I could just hear it. Tires on gravel. A heavier crunch than my car made, a ways back.
The road ahead got worse. Grass up the middle. A sign said MINIMUM MAINTENANCE ROAD, TRAVEL AT YOUR OWN RISK. In my high beams I could see where it dropped down toward a creek bottom and turned into two dirt ruts.
I stopped. It was 11:52.
Behind me, the crunching stopped too.
I sat there with my foot on the brake and the engine running. I could smell my own dust drifting back past the open window, and under it, faint, exhaust that wasn’t mine. Close enough to smell.
Nothing moved. Nobody honked. Nobody got out. It just sat back there in the dark, idling, waiting to see what I’d do.
I’d like to say I made a plan. I didn’t. I cranked the wheel, backed into the ditch, and did a three-point turn in about five points, scraping my front bumper on the far bank. Then I floored it back the way I came.
When I passed the truck, its headlights came on. High beams, full in my face, so I couldn’t see the driver or the plate or anything. Just white. Then they went off again.
It didn’t follow me. I’ve thought about that a lot. The best I can figure is that it didn’t have to.
I found my way out by driving toward the only lights I could see, a grain elevator, and then the glow of the highway. I came out on Highway 4 about three miles east of where I’d turned off.
Where the Fake Detour Had Been
I drove west past the spot where the detour had been.
There was nothing there. No barricade, no flasher, no cones, no signs. The highway was clear and dry and fine in both directions.
I drove twenty more minutes to the next town and called the sheriff from the parking lot of a closed bank.
The deputy who met me was named Kurt Bachmeier. Big guy, calm, a little skeptical at first. I told him about the detour, and he got very quiet.
“There’s no roadwork on 4,” he said. “Not this month. Not this year.”
He had me lead him back to the turnoff. He walked the shoulder with a flashlight. He found four square dents in the gravel where something heavy had stood, and one orange cone lying in the ditch, like somebody had missed it in a hurry. He put the cone in his trunk.
Then he asked me to tell it again from the start. The whole night. The farmer, the pot roast, the gas station.
He stopped me at the gas station.
“He told you to watch for orange?”
I said yes.
“And what did he say about your taillight?”
He walked to the back of my Impala, opened the trunk, pulled back the liner, and twisted out the bulb socket for the left taillight. He gave it a quarter turn back in, and the light came on.
“It’s not burned out,” he said. “Somebody turned it loose.”
It had been working that afternoon. I knew it had, because the farmer stood behind my car while I backed out of his machine shed, and he’s the kind of man who would’ve said something.
Deputy Bachmeier looked at me for a long time.
“They didn’t need your light to put the signs out,” he said. “They needed it to know which car to follow. At night, on a road like that, you’re the only set of taillights with one missing. You could pick that out from a mile off.”
He called me two days later. They’d pulled the video from the gas station camera. The man in the canvas coat had been parked there almost three hours before I pulled in. He talked to two other drivers that night. A trucker, and an older couple in a minivan. He never went near either of their vehicles.
After I left, he got in his pickup and made a phone call. Eleven seconds, the deputy said. You could see it on the video. Then he drove off east. The opposite direction from me.
The barricade and the signs turned up a week later in a shelterbelt about four miles north. They’d been stolen from a county road shed in a different county back in September. Nobody reported them missing, because nobody had counted.
They never found the red Chevy. They never found whoever was in the truck on that gravel road. Deputy Bachmeier said the best guess was a robbery. Somebody picking out a lone driver in a decent car and walking him out where nobody would hear anything.
He said it like he wanted me to believe it. I didn’t ask what else he thought it could be. I didn’t want to know what was down in that creek bottom past the end of the road.
I check my taillights at every gas station now. Both of them, before I pull out.
And when somebody asks which way I’m headed, I point the other way.
Have a fake detour horror story of your own?
Have you ever followed a detour that didn’t feel right? Tell us your fake detour horror story, or any highway horror stories from an empty road at night, in the comments below.
How scary was it?
More Highway Horror Stories
A Man Walked Up to My Car at the Closed Interstate and Said They Opened It for Us
A Voice on My CB Counted Down the Miles to Where He Was Waiting
The Payphone at the Rest Stop Rang, and It Was for Me
The Rest Stop at the End of the Highway
I Ran Out of Gas on an Empty Road at 2 AM
The Car That Followed Me for 40 Miles