Never Tell the Man in the Gray Suit What Time It Is

Polite man in a gray suit and hat holding a pocket watch on a dim train platform at night, creepiest urban legends

Some of the creepiest urban legends have nothing in them that sounds scary when you say it out loud. In Baltimore, the one my grandfather told me is about a man in a gray suit who asks you what time it is. That’s it. He’s polite. He has a nice hat. He asks the time. … Read more